If you're an insurance agent struggling to hit consistent high-income months, this post is for you. We’re breaking down exactly how Tyler Green, a full-time agent, went from making $10K–15K a month to consistently clearing $30K–$50K+ every single month — with the help of Agent Lead Lab.

How to Consistently Make $35K/Month as an Insurance Agent with Agent Lead Lab

June 20, 2025•4 min read

If you're an insurance agent struggling to hit consistent high-income months, this post is for you. We’re breaking down exactly how Tyler Green, a full-time agent, went from making $10K–15K a month to consistently clearing $30K–$50K+ every single month — with the help of Agent Lead Lab.

Whether you're brand new or already building an agency, here’s how Tyler used Agent Lead Lab’s lead system, training, and ownership model to build a scalable income machine.

The Turning Point: From Burnout to Breakthrough

Tyler started in the insurance industry like many — hungry, broke, and working out of his mom’s house. He got licensed in 2020, and by 2021 he was all in.

But for the first year or two, income was inconsistent. He was grinding hard but not breaking through. That changed the moment he shifted two key things:

He upgraded his lead quality (to high-intent Facebook leads)
He added a power dialer and tightened his process

These two moves took him from $15K months to $30K+ months. When you talk to better leads and reach them faster, your whole game changes.

The Agent Lead Lab Difference

Before Agent Lead Lab, Tyler was using a vendor with minimal support. It was transactional: buy the leads, get a PDF, figure it out yourself.

What made Agent Lead Lab different?

Hands-on support
A real team that communicates
Customized lead targeting based on top-performing states
Flexible options for scaling

Tyler didn’t just buy leads — he plugged into a full ecosystem that supports agents at every stage.

From Lead Buyer to Lead Owner: The Apex Package

Once Tyler saw consistent results, he leveled up again by investing in Agent Lead Lab’s Apex Ownership Package. Instead of renting leads, he started owning his system and using it to:

Build his agency
Reduce long-term costs
Help other agents (even outside his team)
Turn leads into an asset, not just an expense

This wasn't just a financial move. It was a business model shift. Now Tyler controls his own lead pipeline and profits from it.

What’s the Secret? Communication & Consistency

Tyler credits a huge part of his success to staying in close communication with the Agent Lead Lab team. He didn’t just "set it and forget it." He asked questions, made adjustments, and worked his leads daily.

His advice?

“You don’t need to be a sales god. You just need to work hard, follow the script, and lean on the team.”

Working the Leads: Strategy Matters

Here’s how Tyler works his leads to get consistent results:

New Leads: Start with the freshest lead, double-dial, and call 2–3x/day (morning, afternoon, evening).
Aged Leads: Don’t sleep on aged leads. Call consistently. Use the beneficiary name as your anchor (“You put down John as your beneficiary — remember that?”)
Mindset: Don’t judge leads too early. Give it a full 3–4 weeks before making decisions.
Script: Stay calm, natural, and clear. Tyler’s tone is confident but laid back — no hype, no pressure.

“The leads get better the longer you work them. You’re not chasing — you’re solving a problem they already said they had.”

Pro Tips for New Agents

Start with at least a month of leads — not a week.
Be coachable — use the scripts, listen to feedback, and ask questions.
Show up consistently — this is a volume game. Missed dials = missed income.
Pick the highest package you can afford — higher volume = faster data = faster success.

Why It Works

Agent Lead Lab isn’t just about “leads” — it’s about building systems. When agents have a repeatable, scalable process, they stop guessing and start growing.

Here’s what you get with Agent Lead Lab:

Real-time high-intent leads
Support from actual humans (not a faceless email)
The option to own your lead funnel
Advice tailored to your state, product, and goals

Final Word from Tyler:

“If you're serious, don’t dabble. Go all in for a month. Work the leads like it's your last shot. Communicate with the team. And just watch what happens.”